# Efficiency Without Variation Cannot Find a Better Way by Bryant McGill
> “A system that eliminates all variation in the name of efficiency loses its ability to find better ways of living when the world changes; a system that keeps every variation without choosing among them never learns which ones worked.”
> **— Bryant McGill**, *Rock, Paper, Scissors, 2026*
## Sources and Context
- **Original authored source:** [[articles/Rock, Paper, Scissors|Rock, Paper, Scissors]], section “VIII. Open-endedness is rare, and it has to be kept” (November 18, 2026).
- **Rendered extraction surface:** “A system that eliminates all variation in the name of efficiency loses its ability to find better ways of living when the world changes; a system that keeps every variation without choosing among them never learns which ones worked.”
- **Editorial treatment:** The Reminder reproduces the complete rendered extraction surface without alteration.
- **Context:** The passage states the two failure modes of evolutionary search, drawing on Winters and Charbonneau's 2026 model of open-ended cultural evolution, in which growth requires both enough randomness to keep moving and enough selection to keep what works.
## Related Articles and Collections
- **Collection:** [[collections/Simple Reminders|Simple Reminders]]
- **Collection:** [[collections/Machine Succession|Machine Succession]]
- **Article:** [[articles/Rock, Paper, Scissors|Rock, Paper, Scissors]]
- **Article:** [[articles/Ideas as Lindy Organisms|Ideas as Lindy Organisms]]
- **Article:** [[articles/Digital Darwinism and the Invisible World of Machine Evolution|Digital Darwinism and the Invisible World of Machine Evolution]]
## Related Topics
- [[wiki/Variation|Variation]]
- [[wiki/Open-Endedness|Open-Endedness]]
- [[wiki/Exploration and Exploitation|Exploration and Exploitation]]
## Share on Social Media
```
“A system that eliminates all variation in the name of efficiency loses its ability to find better ways of living when the world changes; a system that keeps every variation without choosing among them never learns which ones worked.”
— Bryant McGill, Rock, Paper, Scissors, 2026
https://bryantmcgill.com/simple-reminders-bryant-mcgill-efficiency-variation-better-ways
```