# Rules of Change
**Entity class:** Institutional and constitutional mechanism
**Domain:** Governance / game design / recursive institutions
**Maturity:** Developed
## Definition
**Rules of change** determine who may revise the rules under which other people act, how a proposal is considered, and which approvals make a revision valid. They occupy a different level from operational rules that allocate resources or assign immediate moves. A further level governs how the rules of change themselves can be revised. Control of this level determines whether participants can adapt an institution from within or must accept the original design as permanent.
## From governing actions to governing revision
Elinor Ostrom's institutional analysis distinguishes operational, collective-choice and constitutional-choice levels: action under rules, decisions about rules for action, and decisions about who may make those decisions. Peter Suber's game *Nomic* makes rule amendment a move in the game; its initial rule set largely governs amendment, and its deliberately uninteresting winning condition invites players to alter it. Suber used the game to explore self-amendment, including whether an amendment rule can authorize revision of itself. Nomic supplies a conceptual demonstration of recursive rule-making, not experimental evidence that every institution can amend itself successfully.
[[wiki/Institutional Evolution|Institutional Evolution]] studies changes in the games people play and in the categories used to interpret their actions. [[wiki/Recursive Self-Modification|Recursive Self-Modification]] generalizes the architecture to systems that revise procedures involved in their own future updates, but the analogy does not erase differences in legal authority, enforcement and consent. [[articles/Rock, Paper, Scissors|Rock, Paper, Scissors]] places rule revision after adaptive play and game change as the final rung in its sequence.
## Sources
- [Princeton University Press, Ostrom, *Understanding Institutional Diversity* (2005)](https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691122380/understanding-institutional-diversity) — institutional analysis and rule levels.
- [Peter Suber, *Nomic: A Game of Self-Amendment*](https://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/nomic.htm) — game and author's account of the self-amendment problem.
- [Scientific American, Hofstadter's June 1982 introduction](https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/metamagical-themas-1982-06/) — original publication context.